We stopped the rocket

Construction of a Vertical Launch Site near Granot Loma and directly on the shore of Lake Superior was proposed by the Michigan Aerospace Manufacturers Association (MAMA) as part of the Michigan Launch Initiative. Recognizing the immeasurable value of Lake Superior's freshwater resources, CSCLS began a grassroots campaign to stop the rocket. In November of 2023, after a 3 year campaign, the Powell Township Board passed a resolution to prevent rezoning of Granot Loma for a launch site, effectively stopping the rocket.

Timeline of Events:

 

May 7, 2019: On MAMA's request, the Marquette County Board of Commissioners asked the State of Michigan to invest $750,000 into the establishment of a spaceport at Sawyer International Airport. Read more [PDF Page 14]

July 7, 2019: Marquette County Board stated at one of its meetings that Sawyer International Airport would be evaluated for Spaceport potential under a $2 million allocation from the governor. 

August 20, 2019: The Board stated that Explorer Solutions had been hired "to assist with efforts to establish a spaceport at Sawyer International Airport". Read the results of the Explorer Report here.

 

July 23, 2020: MAMA made a surprise announcement on the County Courthouse steps of its plans to establish a vertical launch site at Granot Loma. Read more

For a more detailed recount of how MAMA switched its plans and misled the people and governments of Marquette County, read our article: The Bait & Switch Behind the Granot Loma Launch Plan

July 27, 2020: A Change.org petition went into effect opposing the rocket launch site, quickly accumulating thousands of signatures to protect our shoreline from this industrial interest. Sign CSCLS's general petition here.

October 2020: Citizens for a Safe & Clean Lake Superior was created as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit.

May 4th, 2021: MAMA CEO Gavin Brown attended a Marquette County Board of Commissioners meeting to give public comment regarding the Michigan Launch Initiative and Spaceport Plan. Watch video of his comment here (40:25-1:19:16)

November 2021: Through a FOIA request to the MI Economic Development Corporation (MEDC), CSCLS uncovered an economic feasibility study commissioned by MAMA and completed by nonprofit research entity IQM. This report concluded that the spaceport and its accompanying public-private partnership is not economically feasible. Read the IQM report here.

 

April 24, 2022: The New Yorker released a comprehensive article about the proposed spaceport project. Read the article here.

 

June 2023: CSCLS released a Noise Pollution Report we commissioned to document the likely noise pollution that would result in the surrounding community if a spaceport was established at Granot Loma, concluding that launches from Granot Loma would have a significant impact on the local environment within up to a 50 mile radius. Read the report here.

 

June 2023: CSCLS filed a petition for a zoning amendment in Powell Township to completely prohibit spaceports anywhere in the township.

The petition was filed with over 130 supporting signatures (final count: 230) from Powell Township residents and property owners; this is significant given that the Township's population is only 800. To support our initial filing, we included a legal opinion letter from the Conservation Law Center setting out the sound legal basis for the petition, as well as the Noise Pollution Report mentioned above.

 

October 2023: Representatives from CSCLS and Powell Township consulted Powell Township's attorney to discuss the petition and ultimately agreed that an official resolution passed by the township would be more forceful and effective than an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance.

 

November 21, 2023: The Powell Township Board enacted an official Resolution making clear that the Granot Loma rocket launch site is unlawful and prohibited. Read More

The Board found that constructing and operating a rocket launch spaceport at Granot Loma “would not be appropriate or lawful”, would be “illegal spot zoning”, and “would be inconsistent with the current and future land uses and planning goals as defined in the Master Plan of the Township”. 

 

2025-2026: This is when MAMA has claimed the spaceport should be operational, following land acquisition, local zoning changes, and FAA licensing (including an environmental impact assessment). With your support, have prevented this environmental disaster and protected Lake Superior, its watershed and its people from this industrial threat.

 

Overview of the challenge

The proposed rocket launch site was located within Powell Township, on a property referred to as "Granot Loma". The site is located directly on the shore of Lake Superior near Thoneys Point, and is in close proximity of recreation areas such as Echo Lake, the North Country Trail, the Hiawatha Water Trail, the Little Garlic River, the Elliott Donnelly Wilderness Tract, the Eagles Nest Community Forest, and the Noquemanon Trail Network. 

This land is home to:

  • Miles of Lake Superior shoreline
  • Thriving ecosystems with diverse wildlife
  • Wetlands
  • Jacobsville sandstone
  • At least 5 houses within the evacuation zone
landmap

Above, land ownership map of a portion of Marquette County, containing the proposed rocket launch site outlined in bright pink

 

Threats the Launch Site posed

Pollution

 

Even after successful launches, pieces of rockets, containing kerosene propellent residue, would fall into the lake or land below, including nose cones, large battery packs, engines, and rocket body pieces. During rocket failure, the entirety of the rocket would end up in Lake Superior or in the adjacent coastal forest.

Rocket launches risk physically contaminating Lake Superior, surrounding rivers and streams, and soil. At Pacific Spaceport in Kodiak, Alaska, rocket launch failure led to the contamination of 230 metric tons of soil, which had to be excavated and treated off-site. 

Rocket launches would also introduce sound pollution. Sound pollution significantly impacts wildlife, especially birds, land mammals, and echolocators. Additionally, launches noise would disrupt humans for miles around. 

The construction of at least 3 lighting towers with heights of about 100 feet tall would pollute the area's dark sky. 

Read Environmental Issues Surrounding the Proposed Marquette Spaceport

Habitat Destruction

 

The construction of a spaceport would include the clear cutting of boreal forest and destruction of wetlands. This eradication of habitat threatens wildlife and important ecosystems. 

IMG_1201

Granot Loma as it is today

Aerial,Image,Of,A,Rocket,Launch,Facility,In,Florida,Usa

A launch pad at a vertical rocket launch site

Evacuation

 

For each rocket launch, surrounding areas would be required to evacuate. This includes homes, roads, and outdoor recreation areas (both on land and in water). 

At SpaceX's Boca Chica spaceport, locals lost access to roads, public areas, and their only public beach. During launches, Boca Chica residents have been instructed to leave their homes due to risk of launch vibrations shattering windows. SpaceX has now bought many of them out of their homes. 

Lack of economic benefit

 

According to IQMRI's economic report commissioned by MAMA, “the annual revenue generated from a launch cadence of one rocket launch per week in Michigan would have the same revenue impact in the State equal to the annual revenue of two additional fast-food chain restaurants". 

IQMRI reported MAMA's plan to be "not self-sustaining nor economically viable" and characterized investing in the spaceport as "high risk and low return".  

 

For current news, click below!